venerdì 20 settembre 2013

Navtex - Confronto fra alcuni decoder software

Ho voluto testare le prestazioni dei più comuni software per la decodifica dei segnali Navtex partendo da una registrazione di circa un minuto effettuata sui 518 kHz in modo USB ed in modo CW.
La qualità del segnale registrato non era volutamente perfetta in modo da misurare le capacità dei singoli software nel decodificare correttamente i messaggi anche in presenza di rumore o disturbi.
Questo test non ha pretese di avere un livello "scientifico", ma solo quello di comparare i diversi risultati ottenuti nelle mie condizioni di lavoro, utilizzando cioè un computer certamente non di ultima generazione e sul quale alcuni programmi, a causa della loro struttura, avrebbero potuto trovare delle difficoltà a compiere il loro lavoro.
La decodifica è stata ripetuta più volte in modo di avere il miglior risultato possibile.
Questi sono i risultati ottenuti:

  1. Frisnit Navtex Decoder v215 - In USB decodifica al 95% - In CW decodifica quasi nulla
  2. Multipsk - Sia in USB che in CW la decodifica è al 100%
  3. JVComm32 - In USB decodifica al 90% - In CW decodifica al 80%
  4. SeaTTY - Sia in USB che in CW la decodifica è al 100%
  5. Yand - In USB decodifica al 99% - In CW decodifica al 80%

Da segnalare una certa difficoltà iniziale nell'agganciare la sincronia da parte di JVComm32 ed in misura minore da Yand.
Qui nel dettaglio i messaggi decodificati:

Modo USB


1 - Frisnit Navtex Decoder v215

R GULF OF GENOA WITH LITTLE CHANGE.
HIGHPRESSUR AROUND 1016 OVER SOUTHWEST OF FRANCE BUILDING A N
AND EXPECTED AROUND QPQIM

EAST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
NORTHWEST 8, BACKING WEST IN MORNIN. GUSTS.

WEST OF ROVNCE.
CONTINUING TO 18/00 UTC.
NORTHWEST  8 USTS.

SOUTH OF LIGURE.


2 - Multipsk

GULF OF GENOA WITH LITTLE CHANGE.
HIGH PRESSURE AROUND 1016 OVER SOUTHWEST OF FRANCE BUILDING AT END
AND EXPECTED AROUND 1018.

EAST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
NORTHWEST 8, BACKING WEST IN MORNING. GUSTS.

WEST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 18/00 UTC.
NORTHWEST  8. GUSTS.

SOUTH OF LIGURE.


3 - JVComm32

HIGH P_EYSURE_ARO_ND_1016 OVER SOU_H_EST OF_FRANCE BUILDING S_ _N____
AND EXPECTED AROUND 1018._

EAST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
NORTHWEST 8, BACKING WEST IN MORNING. GUSTS_M
_
WEST _F PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 18/00 UTC.
NORTHWEST  8. GUSTS.

SOUTH OF LIGURE.


4 - SeaTTY

GULF OF GENOA WITH LITTLE CHANGE.
HIGH PRESSURE AROUND 1016 OVER SOUTHWEST OF FRANCE BUILDING AT END
AND EXPECTED AROUND 1018.

EAST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
NORTHWEST 8, BACKING WEST IN MORNING. GUSTS.

WEST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 18/00 UTC.
NORTHWEST  8. GUSTS.

SOUTH OF LIGURE


5 - Yand

{}ULF OF GENOA WITH LITTLE CHANGE.
HIGH PRESSURE AROUND 1016 OVER SOUTHWEST OF FRANCE BUILDING AT END
AND EXPECTED AROUND 1018.

EAST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
NORTHWEST 8, BACKING WEST IN MORNING. GUSTS.

WEST OF PROVENCE.
CONTINUING TO 18/00 UTC.
NORTHWEST  8. GUSTS.

SOUTH OF LIGURE.


Modo CW in reverse

1 - Frisnit Navtex Decoder v215

AZQ

FOUCT9/0UCA 
ZKPE COKBFZGNE


NNN

ZCZ W38
21RGHMEP
VVMMPUX
ZA
N  P 1 FROM PTO3 


2 - Multipsk

WESTERLY 8 IN BONIFACIO STRAITS AND VICINITY. SEVERE GUSTS.

ELBE.
FROM 18/15 UTC TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
WEST OR SOUTHWEST 8 NEAR CAPE CORSE, AT TIMES 9. SEVERE GUSTS.


NNNN

ZCZC WL38
121541 UTC SEP 13
AVURNAV TOULON 907/13
PROVENCE
ON 15 SEP 13, FROM 0000Z TO 2359Z


3 - JVComm32

WESTERLY _I IN_B_N_F_CI___T_AI_S _ND V______Y_________


ELBE.
FROM 18/15 UTC TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST._
WEST OR_S_UTH_EST_8 NEA_ CAPE CORSE, AT TIMES 9. SEVERE GUSTS.


NNNN

ZCZC WL38
121541 UTC SEP 13
AVURNAV TOULON 907/13
PROVENCE
ON 15 SEP 13, FROM 0000Z TO 2359Z,


4 - SeaTTY

WESTERLY 8 IN BONIFACIO STRAITS AND VICINITY. SEVERE GUSTS.

ELBE.
FROM 18/15 UTC TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
WEST OR SOUTHWEST 8 NEAR CAPE CORSE, AT TIMES 9. SEVERE GUSTS.


NNNN

ZCZC WL38
121541 UTC SEP 13
AVURNAV TOULON 907/13
PROVENCE
ON 15 SEP 13, FROM 0000Z TO 2359Z,


5 - Yand

WESTERLY 8 IN [BONIFACIO] ~~~~~{}INITY. ~~V~~~~{}

ELBE.
FROM 18/15 UTC TO 19/00 UTC AT LEAST.
WES~~~~~~{} NEAR CAPE CORSE, AT TIMES 9. SEVERE GUSTS.


NNNN

ZCZC WL38
121541 UTC SEP 13
AVURNAV TOULON 907/13
PROVENCE
ON 15 SEP 13, FROM 0000Z TO 2359Z,

Nessun commento:

Posta un commento